Research Appraisals
Evidence-based critical appraisals of the latest medical research, systematically evaluated using Oxford CEBM methodology.
Showing 2 appraisals
Acta obstetricia et gynecologica Scandinavica
ChatGPT in urogynecology: Comparing large language model responses to human experts
INTRODUCTION: Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used in healthcare, including urogynecology, where stigma may limit open discussion. LLM-based chat platforms may provide a less intimidating and more accessible way for patients to obtain information, but their reliability requires evaluation. This study compared the quality of ChatGPT-generated responses in urogynecology with those provided by a consultant urogynecologist, focusing on understandability, helpfulness, and reassurance. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A cross-sectional survey was conducted among urogynecology patients. After informed consent, participants reviewed responses to six common questions, each answered by ChatGPT and a single consultant. A blinded third-party consultant verified clinical accuracy. Patients rated responses using a 5-point Likert scale across three domains (maximum score 15 per response). Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used for comparison. RESULTS: A total of 203 patients participated (median age 56 years, interquartile range 46-66). ChatGPT responses received higher total ratings than consultant responses (76 [67-85] vs. 72 [63-80], p < 0.01). Scores were higher for understandability, helpfulness, and reassurance (all p < 0.01). ChatGPT was preferred in four of six questions, one showed no difference, and one favored the consultant. Subgroup analyses showed no significant variation based on patient characteristics. CONCLUSIONS: In this exploratory study, women rated ChatGPT's responses as clearer and more reassuring than consultant answers. These findings reflect patient perceptions in a limited setting and should be interpreted with caution. While LLMs may have a supportive role in patient education, their use must remain secondary to expert clinical care and subject to careful oversight.
3 Aug 2026
Read appraisal →African journal of reproductive health
Effects of kegel training combined with acupoint application in preventing postpartum pelvic floor dysfunction: A randomized controlled trial
This study investigated the early preventive benefits of combining Kegel exercises with acupoint application at Qi Hai and Guan Yuan points for addressing postpartum pelvic floor dysfunction (PFD). A total of 110 first-time mothers were randomized into two groups: the prevention group, which received the combined intervention, and the control group, which practiced only Kegel exercises. The interventions followed a structured schedule during the postpartum period. At 42 days postpartum, the prevention group showed a notably lower rate of urinary leakage and improved outcomes in Type II pelvic floor muscle strength, ICI-Q-SF scores, and Hamilton Anxiety Scale results (all P<0.05). However, there were no significant differences between the groups in Type I muscle strength, vaginal dynamic pressure, PFDI-20 scores, or anatomical positioning of the bladder and cervix (P>0.05). The treatments were well-tolerated, with only two minor cases of redness and itching at application sites. We conclude that combining Kegel exercises with acupoint application at Qi Hai and Guan Yuan points may effectively reduce postpartum urinary incontinence, strengthen specific pelvic floor muscles, and improve emotional well-being. Cette étude a examiné les bénéfices préventifs précoces de la combinaison d'exercices de Kegel avec l'application d'acupression sur les points Qi Hai et Guan Yuan pour traiter la dysfonction du plancher pelvien (DPP) post-partum. Au total, 110 primipares ont été randomisées en deux groupes : le groupe prévention, recevant l'intervention combinée, et le groupe témoin, pratiquant uniquement les exercices de Kegel. Les interventions ont suivi un calendrier structuré pendant la période post-partum. À 42 jours post-partum, le groupe prévention a montré un taux de fuites urinaires nettement inférieur et de meilleurs résultats pour la force musculaire de type II du plancher pelvien, les scores ICI-Q-SF et les résultats à l'échelle d'anxiété de Hamilton (tous p<0,05). Cependant, aucune différence significative n'a été observée entre les groupes pour la force musculaire de type I, la pression dynamique vaginale, les scores PFDI-20 ou la position anatomique de la vessie et du col de l'utérus (p>0,05). Les traitements ont été bien tolérés, avec seulement deux cas mineurs de rougeurs et de démangeaisons aux sites d'application. En résumé, combiner les exercices de Kegel avec l'acupression sur les points Qi Hai et Guan Yuan pourrait réduire efficacement l'incontinence urinaire post-partum, renforcer des muscles spécifiques du plancher pelvien et améliorer le bien-être émotionnel.
31 May 2026
Read appraisal →