Research Appraisals
Evidence-based critical appraisals of the latest medical research, systematically evaluated using Oxford CEBM methodology.
Showing 2 appraisals
Journal of medical Internet research
Large Language Model Versus Multidisciplinary Team: Feasibility Study of Pancreatic Cancer Management Recommendations
Of 269 pancreatic cancer multidisciplinary team cases, 125 complete structured cases were evaluated. The chat interface model labeled ChatGPT-5.2 matched the multidisciplinary team's broad initial management category in 119 cases (95.2%, 95% CI 89.8%-98.2%). The end point was coarse, and the model was not version controlled, so findings only support supervised exploratory use.
2 July 2026
Read appraisal →Pancreas
Whole Metagenomic Profiling Identifies a Gut Microbial Signature for Chronic Pancreatitis via Machine Learning
BACKGROUND: Pancreatitis significantly alters the microbial composition of the oral and intestinal compartments, causing dysbiosis that may contribute to disease mechanisms and potentially serve as a basis for diagnosis or treatment. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the oral or gut microbial signature can classify chronic pancreatitis (CP). METHODS: Stool samples (n=707) were collected from participants in the Prospective Evaluation of Chronic Pancreatitis for Epidemiologic and Translational Studies (PROCEED). Samples were distributed among 200 healthy (HC), 310 CP, 49 acute pancreatitis (AP), and 148 recurrent acute pancreatitis (RAP). In addition, saliva samples were collected for a subset of participants (n=156). Whole genome sequencing was performed to assess microbiome composition. Machine learning algorithms were utilized to identify a signature with microbial features predictive of CP. RESULTS: Gut alpha diversity was significantly decreased in AP, RAP, and CP compared with HC, with CP exhibiting the lowest diversity. In contrast, oral microbial diversity showed no significant variation across groups. Beta diversity analysis revealed distinct gut microbiome compositions between HC and pancreatitis subtypes, with CP showing the most pronounced differences. Random forest models using gut microbial species demonstrated robust predictive performance for CP using a minimum of 10 species (Area under the curve-AUC: 0.834; accuracy: 0.774). Despite similarities in gut microbiome composition across pancreatitis subtypes, a unique gut microbial signature for CP was identified highlighting the microbiome's potential in CP diagnosis. CONCLUSION: Our study reveals a gut microbial signature predictive of CP using machine learning models in a large US multi-institutional cohort.
6 May 2026
Read appraisal →