Research Appraisals
Evidence-based critical appraisals of the latest medical research, systematically evaluated using Oxford CEBM methodology.
Showing 2 appraisals
JMIR formative research
Virtual Reality-Based Training in Radiologic Technology for Contrast-Enhanced Computed Tomography Brain Imaging: Randomized Controlled Trial
BACKGROUND: Radiologic technology (RT) education faces challenges in bridging theory and practice due to limited clinical opportunities. While virtual reality (VR) enables safe and repeatable practice, a systematic instructional design framework is needed to develop scalable, procedure-focused modules. OBJECTIVE: This study evaluates the Radiologic Technology Virtual Reality (RTVR) framework that integrates 360-degree video capture, instructional overlays, interactive assets, and an immersive content authoring platform to deliver a contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CECT) brain scan module. METHODS: In this open-label, parallel-group, randomized controlled trial, 36 year-2 and year-3 RT students with no prior clinical training in diagnostic radiology at a university hospital in Thailand were randomly allocated (1:1) to a VR group or a conventional document-based instruction (control) group. The VR group completed the VR module, a grounded instructional design framework using 360-degree videos and a structured prebrief and debrief, for 20 minutes using a head-mounted display. The control group studied standard curriculum materials for the same duration. Blinding of participants was not possible. Outcome assessment was blinded. The primary outcome was declarative knowledge gain, assessed using a 20-item multiple-choice test before and after intervention. Secondary outcomes included technology acceptance, student satisfaction, and physiological responses during VR immersion. RESULTS: All 36 randomized participants (VR: n=18, control: n=18) completed the study and were included in the analysis. Experts validated the module as suitable and highly appropriate. Students reported high technology acceptance and satisfaction. Both VR and conventional methods produced substantial gains in declarative knowledge. No statistically significant difference in knowledge gain was detected between groups (test × group: unstandardized regression coefficient β=.056, 95% CI -1.360 to 1.473, P=.94). Year-2 students, who had less prior clinical exposure, showed larger pretest to posttest knowledge gains compared to year-3 students. Physiological monitoring showed a reduction in heart rate across the session, while blood pressure remained stable. No adverse events or VR-related discomfort requiring discontinuation was observed. CONCLUSIONS: The RTVR framework, which uses a real 360-degree video of authentic clinical settings, offers a scalable approach to procedural VR content creation without requiring specialist technical skills, distinguishing it from prior VR studies in radiography. These findings support the RTVR framework as a feasible, evidence-informed supplement to RT curricula for knowledge-focused procedural teaching, with learning outcomes comparable to those of conventional instruction in this context.
29 May 2026
Read appraisal →Medical physics
Spectral deep learning-based patient and bowtie scatter correction for clinical photon-counting CT
BACKGROUND: The presence of scatter in computed tomography degrades image quality, and can be caused by the patient and by other components in the beam path, such as the bowtie filter. While conventional energy-integrating detectors do not provide spectral distinction, photon-counting (PC) detectors are energy-selective and provide spectral information about the incoming X-ray photons. Since each energy threshold is affected differently by scatter, this spectral information implicitly encodes the scatter content of a projection. PURPOSE: The purpose of this work is to investigate how the spectral information can be exploited to improve deep learning (DL)-based scatter correction. Furthermore, the performance of joint and separate patient and bowtie scatter correction will be investigated, addressing that bowtie scatter has not been considered in current DL-based approaches. METHODS: We present a DL-based approach that can estimate bowtie and patient scatter jointly and compare it against a separate correction. We also introduce neural network-based methods that incorporate the spectral information inherent in PCCT for scatter correction. We present networks that estimate scatter for up to four energy thresholds simultaneously. Training and validation was performed with Monte Carlo data as well as with real data measured by a clinical PCCT system. RESULTS: When comparing joint and separate patient and bowtie scatter estimation, both methods reduce the mean absolute error (MAE) from 8 HU to 1 HU. All proposed DSE methods effectively reduce scatter artifacts and perform better than the convolution-based reference approach. Incorporating the spectral information further improves the performance, with the DSE variant with four energy thresholds achieving the best overall results for all thresholds. For all energy thresholds tested, the spectral DSE methods reduced scatter errors originating from the patient and the bowtie in PCCT from up to 8 HU to below 1 HU. In addition to the global MAE, we report a critical MAE (MAE10) restricted to voxels with uncorrected errors > $>$ 10 HU, as such deviations are visually perceptible in soft tissue and exceed the noise level of modern CT systems. In all test cases, the proposed spectral methods reduced the MAE10 from 23.8 HU in the uncorrected images to 1.6 HU after spectral correction. The affected voxels comprised on average 25 % of the image volume, indicating a significant reduction in artifact intensity in the most affected areas. In virtual monoenergetic images (VMI), the application of spectral neural networks resulted in a significant reduction in MAE from ∼ $\sim$ 16 HU to ∼ $\sim$ 2 HU at 45 keV, from ∼ $\sim$ 8 HU to ∼ $\sim$ 1 HU at 70 keV, and from 5 HU to under 1 HU at 100 keV. CONCLUSIONS: This paper presents a combined method for correcting patient and bowtie scatter that delivers results equivalent to separate corrections and thus eliminates the need for multiple networks. Further, we demonstrate that deep scatter estimation can effectively exploit the spectral information available to improve scatter correction, especially for spectral applications, like VMIs. Spectral DSE networks slightly outperformed non-spectral variants, with multiple energy thresholds lead to more accurate estimations. This enables the use of one network for scatter correction and eliminates the need for multiple ones, thereby saving computational cost and complexity.
10 May 2026
Read appraisal →