Successful student learning outcomes in Moroccan higher education: Causal configurations of pedagogical, motivational, and ICT conditions using fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA)

Clinical Snapshot

Key Findings

• P Value: Not reported

• Effect Size: Not specified - mentions 'strong results' qualitatively

• Primary Outcome: Student learning outcomes and academic achievement

• Nnt Or Sensitivity: Multiple 'recipes' identified but specific configurations and their effectiveness not quantified

• Confidence Interval: Not reported

Clinical Application

Moderate - requires institutional commitment to integrated pedagogical approaches and ICT infrastructure Limited direct applicability due to different educational context, though principles of integrated pedagogical approaches may be relevant for Australian universities and vocational education Higher education students and educators, particularly in developing educational systems

Abstract

As the demand for better educational quality and improved student performance grows, institutions face increasing challenges in making their teaching methods more effective to ensure successful learning outcomes. Most practical recommendations tend to focus on isolated effects, but learning success usually results from interconnected factors that work together. Drawing on constructivist Learning Theory, this study examines pedagogical and motivational factors that can positively impact learning results in higher education within Moroccan universities. The main goal is to identify and evaluate the nonlinear individual effects and the interactive causal configurations involving multiple conditions, such as teacher motivation, pedagogical leadership, self-efficacy, instructional innovation, ICT use, and student motivation, on learning outcomes. Empirical data were gathered through a questionnaire completed by 349 Moroccan university students, using measurement scales for key variables. The analysis employed the fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) method, which helps identify different combinations and causal pathways that lead to high academic achievement. Findings suggest that excellent learning outcomes are not caused by a single factor but by the interaction of several interdependent conditions. Different "recipes" can produce similar strong results. Certain combinations, especially those with strong teacher motivation, effective leadership, and strategic ICT use, proved to be reliable configurations, showing that technology is most impactful when integrated into supportive pedagogical and motivational environments. These results can help redefine and evaluate integrated educational policies, considering the complex interactions among individual, pedagogical, and technological factors. This approach promotes more effective and equitable learning environments through coherent bundles of mutually reinforcing interventions, instead of isolated efforts. Ultimately, this research enables educators and policymakers to develop more targeted strategies, utilize resources more efficiently, and improve overall educational effectiveness.