AI-based color vision screening and educational counseling for high school students: An experimental study
Clinical Snapshot
PICO Framework
| P — Population | High school students (adolescents) in Danang, Vietnam (n=527) |
| I — Intervention | Android-based mobile application integrating digital Ishihara-based color vision deficiency (CVD) screening with AI-assisted educational and career counseling |
| C — Comparator | Conventional paper-based Ishihara color vision testing |
| O — Outcomes | Primary: Agreement/concordance between mobile app screening and conventional Ishihara testing for CVD detection; Secondary: Student perceptions of usability, usefulness, and counseling relevance assessed via validated questionnaire |
Bottom Line
This cross-sectional study from Danang, Vietnam, describes an Android app integrating digital Ishihara-based CVD screening with AI-assisted career counseling for high school students. The concept addresses a genuine gap in low-resource school health settings. However, the study has critical methodological limitations that prevent confident clinical endorsement. Most importantly, the central claim of 'high concordance' with conventional Ishihara testing is unsupported by any reported diagnostic accuracy statistics — no sensitivity, specificity, or kappa values are provided. The use of paper Ishihara as the reference standard for a digital Ishihara app creates circular validation. The reported identification of achromatopsia via Ishihara alone is clinically implausible. CVD prevalence is not disaggregated by sex, a fundamental epidemiological requirement. No confidence intervals are reported. The AI counseling component lacks any described evidence base or independent validation. For Australian clinicians and school health practitioners, this study represents an early-stage proof-of-concept rather than a validated clinical tool. Independent validation against a gold-standard reference (anomaloscope), with pre-registered protocols, sex-disaggregated data, and regulatory-grade diagnostic accuracy reporting, is required before clinical or policy adoption can be considered.
Key Findings
P Value: p > 0.05 for between-group comparison of system evaluation scores between students with and without CVD (non-significant)
Effect Size: Not reported quantitatively; described qualitatively as 'high concordance'
Primary Outcome: CVD prevalence of 3.23% (n=17/527) identified by the mobile application; 'high concordance' reported between app-based and conventional Ishihara screening — specific agreement statistics not provided in abstract
Nnt Or Sensitivity: Sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV, and Cohen's kappa not reported — critical omission for a diagnostic agreement study
Confidence Interval: Not reported for any outcome
Clinical Application
mHealth delivery via Android devices is pragmatically feasible in school settings with high smartphone penetration. However, clinical adoption requires: (1) validated screen calibration protocols, (2) demonstrated sensitivity/specificity against a gold-standard reference (e.g., anomaloscope or Farnsworth-Munsell), (3) optometry or ophthalmology oversight for positive cases, and (4) iOS compatibility for broader reach In Australia, CVD screening is not currently mandated in school health programs, though RACGP guidelines acknowledge its relevance for career guidance (particularly for aviation, defence, maritime, and emergency services careers). The TGA would require formal regulatory approval for any diagnostic medical device app before clinical deployment. The Australian context differs substantially from Vietnam: higher access to optometric services, Medicare-subsidised eye examinations, and established referral pathways mean the primary value proposition of this app (low-resource scalability) is less compelling. However, the concept of integrating CVD screening with career counseling has merit for rural and remote Australian schools with limited access to optometrists. The PBS does not subsidise CVD-specific interventions as there is no pharmacological treatment. RACGP would likely recommend this as a supplementary screening tool only, with mandatory referral to a registered optometrist for confirmatory testing. High school-aged adolescents in low-resource settings where conventional CVD screening infrastructure is limited; potentially applicable to school health programs in developing healthcare systems
Abstract
Color vision deficiency (CVD) can negatively affect students' learning experiences and career choices; however, combined screening and educational counseling remain challenging in school settings, particularly in low-resource contexts. Conventional paper-based color vision tests are time-consuming, difficult to standardize, and rarely linked to individualized educational or career guidance. This study aimed to design, implement, and validate an Android-based mobile application that integrates CVD screening with artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted educational and career counseling for high school students. A cross-sectional study was conducted with 527 high school students in Danang, Viet Nam. The application incorporated a digital Ishihara-based screening module and an AI-assisted counseling component. Screening outcomes were compared with conventional Ishihara testing to evaluate agreement, while students' perceptions of usability, usefulness, and counseling relevance were assessed using a validated questionnaire. Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics, independent-samples t-tests, reliability analysis using Cronbach's alpha, and exploratory factor analysis. Seventeen students (3.23%) were identified as having CVD, including red-green, protan, deutan, and achromatopsia (complete CVD). The mobile application demonstrated high concordance with conventional screening results. No statistically significant differences were observed between students with and without CVD in overall system evaluation scores (p > 0.05). The questionnaire showed good internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha = 0.857) and a clear multi-factor structure reflecting students' acceptance of AI-assisted educational and career counseling. These findings indicate that the proposed mHealth application offers a feasible and scalable approach for school-based CVD screening combined with personalized educational and career guidance. The system may serve as a supportive decision-making tool for students and counselors, while further validation under diverse real-world conditions and across different mobile devices is recommended.
References
- 1.Vinh, D., & Yen, P. T. (2026). AI-based color vision screening and educational counseling for high school students: An experimental study. PLOS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0353871
Related Research
Indian journal of ophthalmology
Internet of things in assistive technology for people with visual impairment: A scoping review
1 Aug 2026
BMJ open ophthalmology
Screening for diabetic retinopathy with artificial intelligence in a primary care setting: a comparative cost analysis
1 Aug 2026
Science advances
Multispectral infrared-to-full-color upconversion expanding human vision
1 Aug 2026
This content is for educational purposes for healthcare professionals only and does not constitute clinical advice. Clinical decisions should be based on individual patient assessment, current guidelines, and appropriate specialist consultation. Editorial Standards · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service